| New York Production | |
| Tony Awards | |
| Best Musical | |
| Best Score of a Musical | |
| Best Book of a Musical | |
| Best Scenic Design | |
| Best Lighting Design | |
| Best Featured Actor in a Musical | George Hearn |
| Best Actress in a Musical | Glenn Close |
| Outer Critics Circle Awards | |
| Outstanding Broadway Musical | |
| Outstanding Actress in a Musical | Glenn Close |
| Drama Desk Award | |
| Outstanding Actress in a Musical | Glenn Close |
| Los Angeles Production | |
| Drama Logue Awards | |
| Outstanding Production | |
| Outstanding Original Music | |
| Outstanding Direction | |
| Outstanding Writing | |
| Outstanding Scenic Design | |
| Outstanding Costume Design | |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | |
| Outstanding Performance | Glenn Close |
| Outstanding Performance | Alan Campbell |
| L.A. Drama Critics Circle Awards | |
| Outstanding Scenic Design | |
| Outstanding Lighting Design | |
| Outstanding Costume Design | |
| Outstanding Sound Design | |
| Outstanding Lead Performance | Glenn Close |
| Ovation Awards | |
| Best Musical | |
| Best Scenic Design | |
| Best Costume Design | |
| Best Lighting Design |
