| ACT I | ||
|
The Vaults of Heaven
|
Minster, Baptist Congregation | |
|
Overture
|
The Orchestra | |
| I Never Get What I Pray For | Swallow, Brat, Poor Baby | |
| Home By Now | Swallow, Brat, Poor Baby | |
| It Just Doesn’t Get Any Better Than This | Boone | |
| Whistle Down the Wind | Boone, Swallow | |
| The Vow | Swallow, Brat, Poor Baby | |
| Cold | Edward, Townspeople | |
|
Unsettled Scores
|
The Man | |
| If Only | The Man, Swallow | |
| Tire Tracks and Broken Hearts | Amos, Candy | |
| Safe Haven | Townspeople | |
| Long Overdue for a Miracle | The Children | |
| When Children Rule the World | The Children | |
| How Many Stars? | Priya, Akaash | |
| Salaam Bombay | Akaash, Rani, Ensemble | |
| Annie Christmas | The Man | |
| No Matter What | The Man, The Children | |
|
Act II
|
||
| Try Not to be Afraid | The Man, Swallow | |
| A Kiss is a Terrible Thing to Waste | Amos, The Man, Swallow | |
| If Only (Reprise) | Swallow, Poor Baby | |
| Charlie Christmas | The Man, Swallow, Brat, Poor Baby | |
| Off Ramp Exit to Paradise | Candy | |
| Safe Haven (Reprise) | Townspeople | |
| Wrestle With the Devil | Preacher, Candy, Amos, Townspeople | |
| The Hunt | Sheriff, Townspeople, The Children | |
| Nature of the Beast | The Man, Swallow | |
| Whistle Down the Wind | Boone, Swallow, Brat, Poor Baby |
